Sobre este ejercicio
Un conjunto de datos de 40 filas en una hoja, una celda de respuesta, unos 5 minutos. Se corrige en tu navegador: el valor y la fórmula que lo produce, con comentarios que te dicen qué arreglar.
Cómo resolverlo
- F2
=IF(AND(D2>=4,E2>=12),"Eligible","Not eligible")
AND combines several tests into one: AND(D2>=4,E2>=12) is TRUE only when the rating is at least 4 and the tenure is at least 12 months, and FALSE as soon as either condition fails. Nesting it inside IF turns that TRUE/FALSE into the two labels the policy needs. Filling the formula down applies the same rule to all 40 rows, so the 24 employees who meet only one condition are excluded automatically.
Pitfall 1: AND is a function, not an operator — =IF(D2>=4 AND E2>=12,…) is a syntax error, and =IF(D2>=4,IF(E2>=12,"Eligible","Not eligible"),"Not eligible") works but repeats the else-branch and gets unreadable with a third condition. Pitfall 2: mixing up AND and OR flips the policy; with OR, anyone with 60 months of service would qualify regardless of rating. Pitfall 3: a blank rating compares as 0 and quietly fails the test; decide whether blanks mean "not rated yet" and handle them with IF(D2="",…). Alternatives: =IF((D2>=4)*(E2>=12),…) multiplies the two booleans (1×1 = 1 = TRUE), a pattern you will meet again in SUMPRODUCT; IFS cannot express "both" on its own, so AND stays the right tool. Design: put the thresholds 4 and 12 in cells of their own and reference them with $ so the policy can change without editing formulas; the free-shipping exercise in this track does exactly that.
Otras formas válidas
- =IF(AND(D2>=4,E2>=12),"Eligible","Not eligible") — reference solution
- =IF((D2>=4)*(E2>=12)=1,"Eligible","Not eligible") — booleans multiplied instead of AND (accepted by the value check, but this task asks for AND)
- =IF(OR(D2<4,E2<12),"Not eligible","Eligible") — the same rule stated through its failures
Errores frecuentes
Using OR instead of AND, so an employee with a rating of 3 and 60 months of service shows Eligible — the grader points at that row because only one of the two conditions holds there.
Cómo corregimos
Se acepta cualquier fórmula que produzca el resultado correcto, salvo que la tarea nombre una función: entonces otra función obtiene media puntuación. Comparamos los valores con una pequeña tolerancia y, en el texto, ignoramos mayúsculas y espacios. Un número correcto escrito a mano en lugar de una fórmula obtiene media puntuación. Las tareas de varias celdas obtienen la puntuación completa con el 100% de las celdas correctas y media puntuación desde el 50%. Cuando importa, también cambiamos una celda de entrada en una copia de tu hoja y comprobamos que tu fórmula se adapta.
Respuestas calculadas con las reglas de Excel 365 y comprobadas en nuestro corrector el 16 de noviembre de 2026. Autor: GridBelt team.