About this exercise
A 80-row dataset on one sheet, 3 answer cells, about 8 minutes. Graded in your browser: the value and the formula behind it, with feedback that names the fix.
How to solve it
- G2
=AND(D2<>"",D2<$J$2,F2="") - J3
=COUNTIF(G2:G81,TRUE) - J4
=SUMIF(G2:G81,TRUE,E2:E81)
A conditional-formatting rule of the "use a formula" kind is just a formula that returns TRUE or FALSE for each row, so writing it in a helper column first shows you exactly which rows the rule will colour. AND needs all three tests to hold: D2<>"" (there is a due date), D2<$J$2 (it is in the past relative to the report date) and F2="" (no payment yet). The $ signs lock J2 so every row compares against the same report date when you fill down, while D2 and F2 stay relative and move row by row. COUNTIF and SUMIF then count and total the TRUE rows.
Pitfall 1: in the rule dialog the formula is written for the top-left cell of the selection (A2) and Excel shifts it for every other cell, so the column references need a $ ($D2, $F2) — otherwise the cells in column B would test E and G instead. Pitfall 2: an empty cell compares as 0, so D2<$J$2 is TRUE for an invoice without a due date — 3 invoices here; D2<>"" (or ISNUMBER(D2)) keeps them out. COUNTIFS(D2:D81,"<"&J2,F2:F81,"") gets this right on its own, because COUNTIFS skips blank cells for a "<" criterion. Pitfall 3: < versus <= — an invoice due on the report date (row 77) is not overdue yet; and a paid invoice is never overdue, even a late one, so a rule on the due date alone would also colour the 31 paid invoices whose due date has passed (16 of them were paid late). Alternatives: =IF(AND(...),TRUE,FALSE) is the same with an explicit IF; =(D2<>"")*(D2<$J$2)*(F2="") returns 1 or 0 — enough inside a formatting rule, where any non-zero number counts as TRUE, but this column is checked for TRUE/FALSE; =COUNTIFS(D2:D81,"<"&J2,F2:F81,"") and =SUMIFS(E2:E81,D2:D81,"<"&J2,F2:F81,"") count and total without the helper column. Reporting: TODAY() instead of a typed report date keeps the list live, but the file then changes every day and cannot be reproduced for an audit — many controllers keep the report date in a cell exactly as here. Windows shortcuts: Alt, H, L, N opens New Rule and Alt, H, L, R manages the rules; on Mac use Home → Conditional Formatting → Manage Rules.
Other ways that work
- =AND(ISNUMBER(D2),D2<$J$2,ISBLANK(F2)) — the same tests with ISNUMBER and ISBLANK
- =IF(AND(D2<>"",D2<$J$2,F2=""),TRUE,FALSE) — explicit IF around the same test
- =COUNTIFS(D2:D81,"<"&J2,F2:F81,"") and =SUMIFS(E2:E81,D2:D81,"<"&J2,F2:F81,"") — count and amount without the helper column
- =SUMPRODUCT(--G2:G81) — counts the TRUE values by turning them into 1s
Common mistakes
=AND(D2<$J$2,F2="") without the due-date test: an empty due date counts as 0, so the 3 invoices with no terms (rows 21, 45, 64) show TRUE and the count in J3 comes out 27 instead of 24.
How we grade
Any formula that produces the right result is accepted, unless the task names a function: then another function earns half credit. We compare values with a small tolerance and ignore case and spaces in text. A correct number typed by hand instead of a formula earns half credit. Multi-cell tasks earn full credit at 100% of cells, half credit from 50%. Where it matters, we also change an input cell on a copy of your sheet and check that your formula follows.
Answers computed with Excel 365 rules and checked in our grading engine on November 16, 2026. Author: GridBelt team.