About this exercise
A 125-row dataset on 2 sheets, one answer cell, about 6 minutes. Graded in your browser: the value and the formula behind it, with feedback that names the fix.
How to solve it
- Timesheet!E2
=INDEX(Staff!$D$2:$D$26,MATCH(C2,Staff!$A$2:$A$26,0))
MATCH(C2,Staff!A2:A26,0) answers "which row of the ID list holds this ID?" with a position — a 1 for the first employee, 25 for the last — and the 0 insists on an exact match. INDEX(Staff!D2:D26, position) then returns the cell of the rate column at that same position. The two functions split the lookup into "find the row" and "read the column", which is why the rate column can be anywhere — left, right or on another sheet — and why inserting a column in Staff never breaks the formula.
Pitfall 1: the INDEX range and the MATCH range must be aligned — Staff!D1:D26 with Staff!A2:A26 is off by one and returns the previous employee's rate for everyone, with no error to warn you. Pitfall 2: leaving out the 0 in MATCH switches to approximate match; on this unsorted roster that returns wrong positions silently. Pitfall 3: MATCH returns #N/A when the ID is missing; wrap the whole INDEX in IFERROR or IFNA when the timesheet can contain IDs of leavers. INDEX/MATCH vs VLOOKUP: same result as =VLOOKUP(C2,Staff!$A$2:$D$26,4,FALSE) here, but INDEX/MATCH looks left, survives inserted columns, and on big tables a single MATCH can feed several INDEX formulas (rate, department, name) instead of repeating the search. In Excel 365, =XLOOKUP(C2,Staff!$A$2:$A$26,Staff!$D$2:$D$26) is the one-function replacement; INDEX/MATCH remains the form that opens in every Excel version and in most other spreadsheet tools.
Other ways that work
- =INDEX(Staff!$A$2:$D$26,MATCH(C2,Staff!$A$2:$A$26,0),4) — INDEX over the whole table with a column number
- =IFERROR(INDEX(Staff!$D$2:$D$26,MATCH(C2,Staff!$A$2:$A$26,0)),"Unknown ID") — with a fallback for IDs that are not on the roster
- =XLOOKUP(C2,Staff!$A$2:$A$26,Staff!$D$2:$D$26) — Excel 365 equivalent (not accepted here: this task practices INDEX and MATCH)
Common mistakes
Swapping the roles: =MATCH(C2,Staff!$D$2:$D$26,0) or =INDEX(Staff!$A$2:$A$26,…) — MATCH must search the column that contains the key (IDs), INDEX must return from the column you want (rates).
How we grade
Any formula that produces the right result is accepted, unless the task names a function: then another function earns half credit. We compare values with a small tolerance and ignore case and spaces in text. A correct number typed by hand instead of a formula earns half credit. Multi-cell tasks earn full credit at 100% of cells, half credit from 50%. Where it matters, we also change an input cell on a copy of your sheet and check that your formula follows.
Answers computed with Excel 365 rules and checked in our grading engine on November 16, 2026. Author: GridBelt team.