About this exercise
A 100-row dataset on one sheet, 2 answer cells, about 7 minutes. Graded in your browser: the value and the formula behind it, with feedback that names the fix.
How to solve it
- F2
=IF(ISNUMBER(D2),AND(D2=INT(D2),D2>=$I$2,D2<=$I$3),FALSE) - I4
=COUNTIF(F2:F101,FALSE)
A Whole number rule in data validation accepts an entry only if it is a number, has no fractional part and lies between the minimum and the maximum, both included. The helper column applies the same three tests to the quantities that are already there. ISNUMBER(D2) rejects text — also "15" typed as text, which looks like a number but is ignored by SUM; D2=INT(D2) rejects decimals such as 12.5; D2>=$I$2 and D2<=$I$3 keep the limits in their cells, so 1 and 100 pass and 101 fails. IF runs the tests only when D2 is a number, because AND evaluates every argument and would turn INT("ten") into #VALUE!.
Pitfall 1: =AND(ISNUMBER(D2),D2=INT(D2),…) looks right but returns #VALUE! for the word rows (3, 50): AND does not stop at the first FALSE. Use IF(ISNUMBER(D2),AND(…),FALSE), or wrap the AND in IFERROR(…,FALSE). Pitfall 2: text that looks like a number (rows 9, 94) is not counted by SUM and not accepted by a Whole number rule; convert it with VALUE or Data → Text to Columns before it reaches a total. Pitfall 3: > and < instead of >= and <= reject the limits themselves (rows 7, 76, 92, 101); the dialog's "between" includes both limits. Alternatives: MOD(D2,1)=0 and ROUND(D2,0)=D2 are other whole-number tests — keep them inside the IF as well. A Custom validation rule can use the helper's formula directly: =IF(ISNUMBER(D2),AND(D2=INT(D2),D2>=$I$2,D2<=$I$3),FALSE). Data validation only checks new typing: values already in the column or pasted over it are not re-checked, which is why the helper column (or Circle Invalid Data in desktop Excel) is the audit step.
Other ways that work
- =IFERROR(AND(ISNUMBER(D2),D2=INT(D2),D2>=$I$2,D2<=$I$3),FALSE) — IFERROR turns the #VALUE! of the word rows into FALSE
- =IF(ISNUMBER(D2),AND(MOD(D2,1)=0,D2>=$I$2,D2<=$I$3),FALSE) — MOD(D2,1) is the fractional part
- =IF(ISNUMBER(D2),AND(D2=ROUND(D2,0),D2>=$I$2,D2<=$I$3),FALSE) — ROUND to 0 decimals as the whole-number test
- =SUMPRODUCT(--(F2:F101=FALSE)) — another way to count the FALSE rows
Common mistakes
Leaving out the whole-number test: =IF(ISNUMBER(D2),AND(D2>=$I$2,D2<=$I$3),FALSE) marks 3 decimal quantities such as 12.5 as valid, although the warehouse cannot ship half a unit.
How we grade
Any formula that produces the right result is accepted, unless the task names a function: then another function earns half credit. We compare values with a small tolerance and ignore case and spaces in text. A correct number typed by hand instead of a formula earns half credit. Multi-cell tasks earn full credit at 100% of cells, half credit from 50%. Where it matters, we also change an input cell on a copy of your sheet and check that your formula follows.
Answers computed with Excel 365 rules and checked in our grading engine on November 16, 2026. Author: GridBelt team.