About this exercise
A 90-row dataset on 2 sheets, one answer cell, about 10 minutes. Graded in your browser: the value and the formula behind it, with feedback that names the fix.
How to solve it
- Quotes!F2
=XLOOKUP(C2&D2,Prices!$A$2:$A$61&Prices!$B$2:$B$61,Prices!$D$2:$D$61)
C2&D2 glues the product and the region into one text, and Prices!A2:A61&Prices!B2:B61 does the same for every row of the price list at once, producing a temporary array of 60 combined keys. XLOOKUP then finds the combined key in that array and returns the price from the same row — a two-column match without a helper column. SUMIFS reaches the same number another way: it adds every price whose product and region match, and since each pair appears exactly once, the sum is that single price.
Pitfall 1: joined keys can collide — "AB"&"C" equals "A"&"BC"; insert a separator that never appears in the data (C2&"|"&D2 on both sides) when keys are free text. Pitfall 2: SUMIFS silently sums duplicates and returns 0 for a missing pair, where XLOOKUP returns #N/A; use SUMIFS only when uniqueness is guaranteed and 0 is not a plausible price. Pitfall 3: in Excel 2019 and earlier, the array form needs INDEX/MATCH entered with Ctrl+Shift+Enter: =INDEX(Prices!$D$2:$D$61,MATCH(C2&D2,Prices!$A$2:$A$61&Prices!$B$2:$B$61,0)). Alternatives: boolean algebra =XLOOKUP(1,(Prices!$A$2:$A$61=C2)*(Prices!$B$2:$B$61=D2),Prices!$D$2:$D$61) avoids concatenation; =SUMPRODUCT((Prices!$A$2:$A$61=C2)*(Prices!$B$2:$B$61=D2)*Prices!$D$2:$D$61) is the pre-SUMIFS form; FILTER(…) spills every match, useful when pairs are not unique. Performance: array concatenation evaluates the whole price list for every quote row — fine for thousands of rows, slow for hundreds of thousands, where a helper key column on the Prices sheet is the classic fix.
Other ways that work
- =SUMIFS(Prices!$D$2:$D$61,Prices!$A$2:$A$61,C2,Prices!$B$2:$B$61,D2) — works in every Excel version; relies on each pair being unique
- =XLOOKUP(1,(Prices!$A$2:$A$61=C2)*(Prices!$B$2:$B$61=D2),Prices!$D$2:$D$61) — boolean array instead of concatenation
- =INDEX(Prices!$D$2:$D$61,MATCH(C2&D2,Prices!$A$2:$A$61&Prices!$B$2:$B$61,0)) — INDEX/MATCH array form (Ctrl+Shift+Enter before Excel 365)
- =SUMPRODUCT((Prices!$A$2:$A$61=C2)*(Prices!$B$2:$B$61=D2)*Prices!$D$2:$D$61) — the classic two-criteria formula
Common mistakes
Looking up the product only, =XLOOKUP(C2,Prices!$A$2:$A$61,Prices!$D$2:$D$61): it returns the first region listed for that product (North), which is wrong for every quote line in another region — 24 of 30 here.
How we grade
Any formula that produces the right result is accepted, unless the task names a function: then another function earns half credit. We compare values with a small tolerance and ignore case and spaces in text. A correct number typed by hand instead of a formula earns half credit. Multi-cell tasks earn full credit at 100% of cells, half credit from 50%. Where it matters, we also change an input cell on a copy of your sheet and check that your formula follows.
Answers computed with Excel 365 rules and checked in our grading engine on November 16, 2026. Author: GridBelt team.